We'll use one load throughout: $2,400 for 1,000 loaded miles, with 75 miles of deadhead. The numbers are a sample, so run your own loads through the load profit calculator.
1. Count the deadhead in the rate per mile
The posted rate per mile counts only loaded miles. The truck is paid $2.40 per loaded mile, but it has to run 1,075 miles to earn it. Across all miles, the load pays $2.23. Compare loads on this number, because a higher posted rate can lose to a lower one with less deadhead. The deadhead calculator puts two loads side by side.
2. Work out the real profit
Take out everything the load has to pay for:
- Fuel: $628 (6.5 mpg at $3.80 diesel)
- Other truck costs: $806 ($0.75 per mile)
- Tolls: $40
- Dispatch fee: $192 (8%)
- Factoring: $72 (3%)
That leaves $661, or $0.62 per mile. Add driver pay if you have a company driver.
3. Compare it with your cost per mile
You need your own number here. As a reference, ATRI's 2026 report puts the average motor carrier at $2.336 per mile in 2025, including driver wages and benefits. An owner-operator's costs can look very different, so work out yours with the cost per mile calculator.
This also gives you your limits for the negotiation. Our sample load breaks even at $1,657, and to clear $500 you need $2,219 or more. Below the break-even, you pass, unless the destination makes up for it.
4. Look at where the load ends
A load also decides where the truck will be tomorrow. Before you book, look at the destination on the board:
- How many loads are leaving that area, and at what rates?
- How far will the truck have to deadhead to reach the next good load?
- Is the driver heading home, or further away?
A high rate into a weak market can earn less over the week than a lower rate into a strong one. Judge the two loads together.
5. Check the time and the driver's hours
A property-carrying driver gets up to 11 hours of driving in a 14-hour window after 10 hours off, with a 30-minute break after 8 hours of driving, under the FMCSA hours-of-service rules. Check that the pickup and delivery times are actually reachable with the hours the driver has left.
Also compare profit per day, not just per load. A load that ties the truck up for an extra day has to earn more to be worth it.
6. Check the broker last, but always check
If the numbers work, look at the broker before you call: credit score, days to pay and, above all, whether your factoring company will buy the invoice. Our guide covers how to check a freight broker's credit in five steps.
Then make the call
You now have a break-even, a target rate and a reason for your number. If the broker's rate falls short, you can make a specific counteroffer or pass without wondering. If you email instead, our broker email templates include a rate offer and a counteroffer.
LoadSense is an independent product by INNOSOFT SOLUTIONS SRL. DAT and DAT One are trademarks of their respective owners; we are not affiliated with or endorsed by them.